Modi is giving only lip service to Nehru and Indira. Modi must emulate Nehru and Indira to develop India. Make in India is not equal to #MadeinIndiabrand. #MakeinIndia is a frank admittance of failure of India to produce any thing from withing India. Make in India will make India a bystander while foreigners manufacture products of their own patents. Made in India is different. Made in India brand comes when Indians and Indian companies produce some thing with their own patents. So Make in India concept is acceptance of India's failure to produce or manufacture on their own. So there is nothing to celebrate on this make in India concept.
The above comment was made by me in Times of India in response to a news item entitled,
" PM Narendra Modi unveils key labour reforms to end 'inspector raj'Looking to create an environment conducive to industrial development while also ensuring transparency in labour sector, Modi launched a host of schemes today.Times of India"
responses to my comment are as follows:
Look at the following statement from our PM, this has nothing to do anything with industrialization of the country.
Prime Minister of India, Mr Narendra Modi said while introducing the programme in his maiden Independence Day speech from the ramparts of the Red Fort on August 15, 2014. “I want to tell the people of the whole world: Come, make in India. Come and manufacture in India. Go and sell in any country of the world, but manufacture here. We have skill, talent, discipline and the desire to do something. We want to give the world an opportunity that come make in India,” The initiative was formally introduced on September 25, 2014 by Mr Modi at Vigyan Bhawan, New Delhi, in the presence of business giants from India.
comments from several readers are given as hereunder :
Yogesh730: If Nehru and Indira would have developed India ,what was the need of make in india???
1 day ago
JP's response to the above comment of Yogesh: Development is nothing but coping with the needs of increasing population. Nehru did his best to feed India's population by constructing river training projects like Dams, barrages across India. He provided us the infrastructure like Steel manufacturing units. Indira striven her best to keep India self reliant in defence arena. Either Mangalyaan or Phokran II would not have been possible if Indira was not there. After Indira India has fallen on all fronts. Now India has become subservient country. When the then PM Chandra Sekhar sold Gold for the sake of debt repayments there was hulla bulla about the issue. But now from Manmohan to Modi PMs are selling the country - allowance of walmart, increase in FDI in insurance, strategic alliance and the like are any indication.
1 day ago.
"Name" has replied like this, "Accept the reality.... India is not a manufacturing superpower".
Uttam Jaiswal: Talking about FDI, FDI and make in India is better than importing, be it defence or anything else. For made in India, it is you and me who have to do something rather than the government. Government can only encourage entrepreneurs, not create them.
1 day ago.
JP's response to the above comment of Jaiswal: We boast of economic reforms but do little to encourage Industrialization of the country. Industrialists are seen as traders. Government policies are not conducive for Industrial enterprise. If at all any enterprise is going on now is because of fringe benefits we get because foreign companies are given the benefit by the government. Only Industries that flourish are the companies which get zero interest capital. Let me clear, big companies which sell shares need not pay dividend immediately. And Big companies are lent @ 5 to 6% interest rate. Whereas a small entrepreneur is charged 14 % interest by the Government owned Banks. Manufacturing costs transport costs in India are so high that we cannot compete with foreign goods. you know in China elctricity is so cheap and banks lend @ 2 to 5 % interest rates. When there is economic slow down in the US interest rates are cut some times event 0.50%. Where as in India when there is economic crisis interest rates are increased. So please let us know that Indian Government acts against indian entreprenuers and favours foreigners instead.
1 day ago
Uttam Jaiswal: Made in India requires people innovating as well as putting in capital. Make in India would bring in the capital, which would address massive unemployment, as well as newer technologies which might trigger ideas in the minds of future entrepreneurs.
1 day ago.
JP's response to the above comment of Jaiswal: Make in India does not bring in technology to India. Technology would be in the hands of the foreign manufacturer only. And capital that would be brought into Indian investment sector creates little employment because high tech manufacture is not labour incentive. Moreover capital in terms of dollars is used by the Government for the purpose of debt repayments ( Balance of Payments ). It is the failure of Governments for the last two decades to strengthen Indian economy in all fronts - agricuture, industry alike.
Vivek A replied like this, "Emulate Nehru and Indira which us brought us to this low. Come on Man!!Make IN India is a mode of transformation to gain ourselves int he manufacturing sector which has been low all throughout. I think this is the best way to move forward and more over this will give jobs to many and this is the best and expedite way to utilize the large indian workforce. God Bless You!!"
pkekade replied like this, "You have hit the perfect nail. Very True !!! But we need to understand that what 'Made in India' couldn't achieve (job creation) is at-least targeted and tried to be achieved my 'Make in India' concept. ............ If we can't get the whole 'Thali' in one go, let us try for 'Dal-Rice' first through different ways. Then we can device a new strategy to get the 'Dessert'."
kumarskanda's response to my comments:
Please do not comment just for sake of comment. Make in India is in addition to Made in India thereby we also get the potential to generate incremental employment and development of local sector economies. If we launched our satellites earlier from a foreign rocket base it did not mean that one day we can do it in our soil itself. Pessimists and Negative thinkers please continue with your thinking. INDIA is moving. It has already launched Mangalyan.
Click on the following LINKS to view my You tube Videos on the issue of,
Click the following buttons to visit my other Websites:
నా ఇతర వెబ్ సైట్లు చూడడానికి ఈ క్రింది బటనులు నొక్కవలెను.